Hydrogen sulfide
The gas behind the rotten-egg taste and odor in well water — produced by soil and rock chemistry, by sulfur bacteria in the well or plumbing, or inside the water heater itself. Also leaves black stains on silverware and fixtures.
The numbers
| Standard | Value | Applies to | Source |
|---|
Treatment families
activated-carbon · greensand · oxidizing-filter · air-injection · chlorination
Hydrogen sulfide gas reaches your tap by four routes, per the Minnesota Department of Health: natural decay and chemical reactions with soil and rock, sulfur bacteria living in the groundwater, well or plumbing, reactions inside the water heater — and, rarely, pollution (MDH, Hydrogen Sulfide and Sulfur Bacteria in Well Water, accessed 2026-11-20).
The water heater route is its own mechanism. Most tanks carry a magnesium anode rod installed to protect the tank from corrosion. That same rod can supply the electrons that convert naturally occurring sulfate into hydrogen sulfide — which is why a rotten-egg smell on the hot side only points at the heater, not the well. MDH’s fixes for that case: replace the magnesium anode with a different material such as aluminum, disinfect and flush the tank, or temporarily raise the tank to 160°F (71°C) to destroy sulfur bacteria — with their explicit caution that raising temperature risks scalding and needs a working pressure-relief valve.
Treatment capacity depends on concentration, which is why the lab number matters before buying anything (MDH figures):
- Activated carbon — effective below about 1 mg/L; service life hard to predict
- Oxidizing media such as manganese greensand — effective up to about 6 mg/L, regenerated with potassium permanganate
- Aeration, continuous chlorination, or ozonation with filtration — effective below and above those levels
Sulfur bacteria themselves are not harmful, but they produce slime (white, grey, black, or reddish when iron bacteria are present) that can clog wells and plumbing and shelter other bacteria. The gas is a different matter in enclosed spaces — see the safety note on the rotten-egg smell diagnosis.
In most cases the smell says nothing about sanitary quality; in rare cases it comes from sewage. MDH’s hedge is cheap and worth copying: test coliform bacteria and nitrate while you’re diagnosing the odor.