Why does my well water smell like rotten eggs?
The rotten-egg odor is hydrogen sulfide gas. One faucet comparison tells you whether it comes from the well, the plumbing, or the water heater — and each source has a different fix, at a very different cost.
Likely causes
| Cause | How common | What distinguishes it | Aesthetic threshold (EPA secondary, public systems) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hydrogen sulfide | common | Odor on BOTH hot and cold taps after hours away points to the well, groundwater or plumbing; odor on the HOT side only points to the water heater — sulfur bacteria in the tank, or the magnesium anode converting sulfate to hydrogen sulfide (per Minnesota Dept. of Health). | — |
Confirm it
- Be away from the house for a few hours, then smell hot and cold taps separately (MDH method)
- Lab test for hydrogen sulfide concentration — treatment choice depends on the number
- Test coliform bacteria and nitrate as well; rarely, the odor traces to sewage
Run the faucet test before spending anything. The Minnesota Department of Health’s method is exactly what a good plumber would do first: leave the house for a few hours, come back, and smell the cold tap and the hot tap separately (MDH, Hydrogen Sulfide and Sulfur Bacteria in Well Water, accessed 2026-11-20).
Hot side only — the problem lives in the water heater, and the well is innocent. The tank’s magnesium anode rod can drive the conversion of sulfate to hydrogen sulfide, and the warm tank is a comfortable home for sulfur bacteria. The fixes are heater-scale, not well-scale: an anode swap to another material such as aluminum, a disinfect-and-flush, or a supervised temperature treatment — details and cautions on the hydrogen sulfide record. This is the cheap outcome, which is why the faucet test comes first.
Both sides — the gas is arriving from the well, groundwater or plumbing. If sulfur bacteria are established, disinfection of the well and plumbing is the first move; if the gas is in the groundwater itself, treatment is sized by the lab number: activated carbon at low concentrations, oxidizing media or aeration-based systems above that. Those thresholds, and why the concentration decides the equipment, are on the hydrogen sulfide record.
Other confirming signs, per MDH: black stains on silverware and fixtures point to the gas itself; white, grey, black or reddish slime points to sulfur bacteria — and if the slime runs reddish, iron bacteria are likely along for the ride, which connects this symptom to the slime diagnosis and the orange staining diagnosis. A smell that reads more swampy or musty than rotten-egg belongs on the musty smell diagnosis instead.
The smell usually says nothing about whether the water is safe — but because it occasionally traces to sewage, the coliform-and-nitrate test is the cheap insurance to run alongside the diagnosis.